Indiana is the ninth largest farming state. Although dominated by industrial ag — think monocrop fields of soy and corn grown for export — many agriculture experts and farmers believe Indiana is poised for its agriculture to pivot and diversify or to stagnate in an increasingly difficult economy, complicated by tariffs driving a fickle market.

In fact Indiana produces $4.58 billion dollars of corn every year and nearly as much soybeans. In contrast California’s almond crop, which supplies most of the world, is only worth $5.6 billion annually. Indiana is also the nation’s number one producer of popcorn.

Terry Engstrand, who owns and operates White Oaks Bison Farm in Rochester, sees 2026 as a time of opportunity for Indiana farmers.

“I think it’s a good time for small farms to get started,” says Engstrand, whose family has been farming for five generations. “People want to know where their food is coming from,” he states, noting that his bison farm has a strong, reliable, customer base in northern Indiana, including South Bend.

Although the Engstrands have only been raising bison for four years, their emphasis on raising quality animals has paid off, according to Terry Engstrand. Breeding stock is in high demand — there are only roughly 200,000 bison in the U.S. — and yearling bison bulls often sell for $3,500 to $4000 dollars in the Midwest. Agriculture is consistently a difficult way to make a living– about 40% of American farmers work 200 or more days at an off-farm job, according to the USDA. Still, current meat and breeding stock prices offer some real hope and favor the savvy producer.

“We’ve found that customers are willing to pay a little extra,” says Terry Engstrand of his loyal customer base. He adds that ground bison burger goes for roughly $16 per pound and demand is steady and consistent.

Raising bison isn’t without its difficulties, admits Engstrand.

“It’s definitely a little more challenging than raising cattle,” he notes, explaining that his agricultural background is deeply rooted in raising beef cattle. Bison require more robust fencing than cattle, and their temperament can be less docile. The Engstrands know the ins and outs of fencing livestock. In addition, Terry Engstrand states that keeping the animals well-fed and content — with access to appropriate minerals, water, hay and pasture at all times — limits all sorts of problems.

Engstrand also recognizes broader difficulties for Indiana farmers.

“In Indiana, there’s so much growth in the cities, it’s sometimes pushing heritage farms out,” he says, noting that this is especially a problem in the northern part of the state. Engstrand also states that interest rates for ag loans can be high, sometimes in double digits in his area, making it hard to buy land, stock, and equipment — all of which are getting more expensive every day.

The average age of an Indiana farmer is 56, a common trend across the country, according to the USDA census of agriculture. At 29, Evan Gunthorp of Gunthorp Farms in LaGrange, Indiana, is bucking the trend. When asked if he is hopeful about the future of Indiana agriculture, Gunthorp says, “It depends on who you are,” emphasizing that agriculture in the state has been geared toward large, industrial-sized operations, Gunthorp adds that there is opportunity for smaller producers.

“You have to really carve out a niche,” he states.

Gunthorp Farms’ niche is selling their products, including pasture-raised pork, directly to customers. Between wholesale accounts with restaurants in Chicago and other cities and direct retail sales, Gunthorp Farms is thriving. Evan Gunthrop makes his living from agriculture– avoiding the off-farm job that supports many farms. However, Gunthorp admits that selling direct has its challenges. “Then you have to juggle a lot of interconnected things. You can’t be mediocre at anything,” he states.

One of the interconnected puzzle pieces on Gunthorp Farms is their own USDA inspected processing plant, finished in 2004. One of the reasons the Gunthorps focused on building their own slaughterhouse was that it enabled them to have control over the timing of marketing and delivery.

“You have to have control over the timing — what the chef needs at any particular moment,” says Gunthorp.

With the ability to process up to 100 hogs a day, Gunthorp Farms has claimed a level of independence that often eludes family-sized farms in Indiana. Even with their success, Gunthorp sees several other obstacles on the agricultural horizon. With an acre of land averaging $13,000 in his area and prime farmland often being divided into suburban-oriented lots, Gunthorp knows it is hard for a farmer just starting out.

“The land is valued as a 7-acre lot supported by a job in town,” he states.

Gunthorp’s parents were the moving force behind making sure the farm had its own USDA-inspected processing plant. “Mom and Dad really bootstrapped it,” Gunthorp says, acknowledging that years of experience working with the facility has taught the Gunthorps how it might have been constructed more efficiently. The Gunthorps’ idea of claiming control over their product is a key concept as Indiana ag progresses into the 21st century.

“The future is very difficult to predict,” says Gunthorp, explaining that competing with huge corporations is always getting harder, especially in a very tight labor market.

“The biggest challenge over the years has been staffing,” says Gunthorp, who notes that many prospective employees want to work on the farming end of the operation but would rather not work in the slaughterhouse.

The elephant in the spacious and productive room that is Indiana agriculture is corn and soybeans grown for export. A world away from Terry Engstrand and Evan Gunthorp’s farms — in a way — are the vast fields of monocrops grown primarily for foreign markets. Although Indiana is the ninth state in agricultural products produced, it is the seventh state in exports, according to the Indiana State Department of Agriculture (ISDA). In fact, Indiana’s agricultural exports totalled $6.358 billion in 2023, according to the ISDA.

Recent tariffs have thrown export-focused agriculture into uncertainty, however. A 2026 study by North Dakota State University (NDSU) states that Indiana farmers lost an estimated $607 million dollars because of tariffs against China, ranking the state ninth for agricultural losses.

Research like that done at NDSU indicates that tariffs led China to seek other countries to purchase agricultural products. At the same time, the tariffs drove up prices on agricultural inputs such as fertilizer and fuel. Indiana agricultural producers were squeezed in the middle.

Beef is a state industry that was particularly affected by tariffs. Because the entire U.S. beef industry is quite integrated with Canada and Mexico and to a lesser extent other global trading partners — tariffs disrupted decades old marketing patterns. Cattle are often fattened and/or slaughtered in Canada and Mexico and many distant markets are the best place for the beef industry to sell cuts not commonly consumed in America — like tongue.

Brian Shuter, executive vice president of the Indiana Beef Cattle Association, is optimistic about the future of Indiana beef, despite recent flooding and other bad weather. Shuter also notes that two processing plants, one in Illinois and one in Pennsylvania, are shutting down, limiting processing options for Indiana beef producers.

While infrastructure will always drive success or failure for agricultural producers, one bright spot in Indiana’s agricultural sector is demand for local products. The South Bend Farmer’s Market, which is open year-round on Saturdays, Tuesdays and Thursdays on Northside Boulevard, usually boasts more than 100 sellers and thousands of shoppers. Diania Franks, the market manager, says the market is quite successful. “We’re doing well,” she says, although she does note that recent rain and wind have caused problems for some local producers.

“Farmers are our first priority,” says Franks, estimating that about a quarter of the sellers are agricultural producers. With most of the farmers selling at the market coming from within 40 miles of South Bend, The South Bend Farmer’s Market shows how family-sized agriculture is thriving with a local flavor in northern Indiana. Despite weather and a sometimes fickle marketplace, local agricultural products are poised to be a growing part of the state’s economy and culture.

Reporter, St. Joe Current.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *