Whether you’re a renter, homeowner, small business owner or retiree on a fixed income, you’re familiar with recent rising rates. A state electric price comparison posted to the Indiana state website shows the average price increase for residential customers from 2017 to 2024 was 20%.

Then, what happened over a 7-year period happened again in just one. Consumer and environmental advocacy group Citizens Action Coalition in 2025 reported a 17.5% year-over-year increase statewide — the highest in two decades. Customers of some providers saw increases of 25% or higher.

You pay about $1,800 a year. In 2017, that was about $1,277.
  • 2017estimate
    $1,277
  • 2024estimate
    $1,532
  • Todayyour bill
    $1,800
  • No sales taxif repealed
    $1,674
The 2025 increase alone: +$268 a year

Meanwhile, recent events — such as an explosion of new AI data centers across the country — may have you worried about even more rate hikes.

The problem is, if you want to keep the lights on, it’s not like you really have options:

It’s just you and whatever big company whose turf you happen to live on, paying whatever they tell you — a figure that keeps rising. In the coming weeks, we’ll take a look at how we got here and what could change in the future. For now, we’ll take a quick look at the companies responsible for supplying Indiana’s power, explore how consumer rates get calculated and explain how you can push back on the next rate hike.

The key players in Indiana power

If you’re in St. Joseph County, you rely upon Indiana Michigan Power (I&M) for electric service. Elsewhere in the state, customers have service from Duke Energy, AES Indiana, NIPSCO or CenterPoint Energy.

These are the five major regulated electric utilities in Indiana. But all those names aren’t options, unless you want to move. Where you live dictates where you get your electricity from, with very little choice or exception.

I&M, for instance, tucks away a tiny link at the bottom of its website called “electric choice.” It leads to pages for residential customers with vague information about “alternative electricity suppliers,” while business customers get multiple pages that haven’t been updated since 2002. And the kicker? This information’s just for Michigan customers, not Hoosiers, who go unmentioned altogether.

Indiana is just one of the balls being juggled by the people behind your power company. Each of these five big players are pieces of larger utility companies operating across the country — and in at least one case, outside the U.S.

I&M is part of American Electric Power, a utility company that claims to serve nearly 5.6 million customers in 11 states with “the nation’s largest electricity transmission system and more than 225,000 miles of distribution lines.”

The other major players in Indiana power are similarly part of much bigger electric operations than the names you know.

Duke Energy calls itself a Fortune 150 company and “one of America’s largest energy holding companies,” serving electricity to a reported 8.7 million customers in six states as well as natural gas to 1.6 million customers in four of those.

AES Indiana (formerly Indianapolis Power & Light Company) is part of AES Corporation, “a Fortune 500 energy company” and “the largest US-based global power company” with regulated power companies in Indiana, Ohio and El Salvador.

NIPSCO, also known as Northern Indiana Public Service Company, serves a reported “900,000 natural gas customers and 500,000 electric customers across the northern third of Indiana,” but as part of NiSource, operates for nearly 4 million customers in six states.

CenterPoint Energy, headquartered in Texas, provides electric infrastructure to more than 2.9 million customers in Texas and Indiana, as well as natural gas to nearly 7 million homes in four states.

Despite having all these major utility companies operating in Indiana, customers don’t really have a wealth of choice in where to get power. And what evidence is there that any of them have made lowering Indiana rates a top priority?”

How your rates are calculated

Okay, so where do the numbers come from, anyway? And what can I do about it?

Power prices are partially set through a lengthy process called a “rate case,” where utility companies pitch regulators on their expenses and investments and how they think rates should be charged to customers.

“Essentially, rate cases cover everything related to how utilities plan to spend and earn money,” writes Karsten Neumeister of the Efficiency Maine Trust. “All states require rate cases for gas and electric utilities.”

A utility company initiates a rate case by offering up expert testimony, accounting and engineering exhibits to the state regulator, which here is the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC). This can cover electric and gas rates and also infrastructure costs like poles, wiring and the like.

The regulator then schedules dates for filings and hearings. This is where the electric company lays out in writing and through testimony what it wants and why, while attorneys representing consumers and others who oppose the plan get to challenge it with questions and testimony of their own. Here’s an example of a timeline used in a rate case for AES Indiana in 2023-24. The entire process can span 10 months or more.

So the first thing I’d do is check out IURC’s news releases and subscribe. That way I can automatically get information about cases involving my utility company. One notice this summer highlighted a meeting about Anderson Municipal Light & Power’s rates, with information for attending in person, submitting written or emailed comments, and how to follow the case online.

In Indiana, these public comment periods happen in the first 90 days of a case, according to a guide from the Indiana Office of Utility Consumer Counselor. For groups such as the Environmental Law & Policy Center, this is a period to advocate on both consumer financial and environmental concerns.

During the public comment period, I can comment through email, online form or physical mail on behalf of myself or someone else. Anyone can — you don’t have to be a utility customer. For particularly large rate cases — where “a utility seeks an increase in revenues that exceeds $2.5 million” — the IURC also holds one or more field hearings where I might speak out in person, like the one mentioned above.

The IURC website explains rate cases and the terminology behind them in more detail, including offering more information about how to participate in a case. Besides commenting, I can access a searchable database of case documents going back to 2001.

Generally, a utility company can’t ask for a basic rate increase more than once every 15 months, the IURC says.

In June, AES Indiana received IURC approval for a base rate increase. Prices rose by roughly $1 per month in July, and an additional estimated increase of $8.50 per month will begin in January 2027. This will be the last requested increase until 2030, the company says.

“The increase supports continued investment in maintaining and improving the electric system customers rely on every day,” as well as keeping service safe and stable, AES Indiana says.

Other financial factors

Rate cases are not the only way consumers can see an increase in their bill, although it is one they can at least publicly speak out against. As AES Indiana acknowledges in a recent newsletter about the base rate increase, “customers may have recently noticed a

change on their bill related to the Fuel Adjustment Charge (FAC),” which “reflects the actual cost of fuel used to generate electricity.” That means it can go up or down, and this summer it went up.

The FAC figure is updated quarterly and speaks to how our utility companies generate power in the first place. The development of alternative and renewable energy infrastructure might possibly make this aspect of the cost equation cheaper. Of course, such projects require time, money and community support.

Don’t new plants themselves lead to rate increases? Not always, if the utility companies can be believed.

I&M plans to build “a 1,520 megawatt natural gas combined cycle generation facility at its Rockport site” in 2027, pending approval from the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission. The plant would be expected to operate by summer 2030. “The project does not impact I&M’s plans to reduce rates for customers,” says a release from I&M.

Another idea being considered by the IURC to lower costs is highlighted in its July 2026 Energy Affordability Report. “It is time that Indiana continues the conversation and evaluates whether to join 40 other states in repealing the sales tax on utility bills,” the report says. The move could reduce utility bills by 7%.

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *